Cruze Aerodynamic Engineering

Project Conclusions

Accurate measurement of aerodynamic drag changes is very difficult. For a DIYer, all methods of measuring drag changes require lots of time and gasoline, and have low accuracy. Therefore, measuring a single modification's effect on the drag coefficient of your car is nearly impossible. For this reason, my conclusion is to make only the modifications which have been proven to work on most vehicles of your body type with past research and data to support. 

Based on my research, modification, and testing, I can recommend the following modifications for a DIYer looking to increase the efficiency of their vehicle:

To Improve Highway Efficiency:


To Improve City Efficiency:


The items on this list are the most DIY friendly, and have the highest chance of increasing efficiency on most cars. To see how I executed many of the items on this list, see the below modification blog. It should be obvious that many of these efficiency strategies come with compromises, challenges, risks, and costs. Each individual must determine which compromises, challenges, risks, and costs they are willing to accept in the name of efficiency. 

Project Efficiency Goals and Testing Methods


Project Goals:


Fuel Consumption will be monitored through the metric of Miles Per Gallon. Distance will be measured using GPS distance travelled data. Fuel required will be measured by the amount of gas required when filling the tank to completely full. To obtain a weighted average of fuel consumption over time, I will keep a running sum of distance travelled and divide that by the running sum of the fuel used. About 65% of my driving is US Midwest highway driving in 55-70 MPH zones. For consistency, I keep a speed of  70-75 MPH in 70MPH zones when possible. When there is congestion or lower speed limits, I go slightly above the average speed of traffic. Though I do utilize strategies to drive efficiently, such as Deceleration Fuel Cutoff, I do not intentionally go slow to save gas. Good MPG data can only be derived from consistent driving habits.


Cooling capacity will be measured using coolant temperature and air pressure measurement. Maximum coolant temperature was measured before modification to be 220F-232F, and will be monitored during modification to ensure the stock maximum temperature is not exceeded. Static air pressure was measured at various speeds before modification in front/behind the vehicle cooling package, as well as in multiple locations within the engine bay. These same locations are measured after each aerodynamic modification to the front end to ensure air is still flowing through the cooling package and out of the engine bay at an acceptable rate. 


Credit: Car and Driver Magazine

Background of the Cruze Eco

The Chevrolet Cruze Eco was marketed as the fuel-saving variant of the Cruze lineup. The GM engineers increased MPG on the Cruze "Eco" model with the following strategies:

The result of aerodynamics add-ons, weight reduction, and powertrain optimization was a 28 City 40 Highway EPA MPG rating. The general consensus was that the GM engineers squeezed every last bit of efficiency out the the Cruze Eco, but I knew that was simply not the case. This blog is the saga of my ongoing quest for higher MPG in my high-mileage Chevrolet Cruze Eco.


The Drivetrain was in a Sad State

Making it Roadworthy

I purchased the car for $3000 sight-unseen in Texas, and drove it 1000 miles home to Illinois. Unexpectedly, it made the trip without any real hassle. However, as expected with a cheap car, it was going to need some serious TLC. The car had clearly been driven for many miles with a failed PCV system, and lots of repairs would be required to bring the engine back to life. The following items were replaced due to failure or future failure avoidance:

Total Spent on Overhaul: $3200 and 3 long weekends

Brainstorming Resistance Reduction Opportunities

Underbody:

- Smooth front bumper undertray with slight downward curvature

- Airdam Delete 

- Full flat engine undertray with directed vents toward rear of engine bay

- Full flat middle undertrays

- Flat rear diffuser with slight 5°-12° upward curvature with strakes


Front End:

- Retrofitted front air curtains

- Reduce area of front upper grille (especially in winter months)

- Cooling air ducting between upper grille and cooling package

- Ducted cooling air between cooling package and exit (wheel well or hood)

- Fully sealed cooling package between grille and heat exchangers

- Adding sealing to the front-end panel gaps (headlights, grilles, hood gaps)


Wheels/Tires:

- Low Rolling Resistance Tires

- Thinner and Lighter Wheel/Tire Setup (215/55/R17 to 205/65/R16)

- Slightly Convex and Smooth Rear Wheel Covers

- Slightly Convex Front Wheel Covers with Small Vents at Outer Edge

- 3-Dimensional front wheel spoilers (spats)

- Partial Rear Wheel Fairings


Other:

- Antenna Relocation

- Rear Side Separation Edges

- Vortex Generators on Rear Sloping Glass for Better Flow Attachment


Additional Opportunities which Conflict with other Project Goals or Safety:

- Full Rear Wheel Fairing

- Full Front Grill Block

- Boat Tail / Box Cavity on Rear End

- Windshield Wiper Removal

Rear Diffuser Undertray

February 2023

My first modification was a large rear diffuser, which in theory would reduce lift and drag. I referenced SAE technical paper 2013-01-0952 "Performance of an Automotive Under-Body Diffuser Applied to a Sedan and Wagon Vehicle" which showed a flat rear underbody diffuser could provide a 0.03 reduction in Cd for sedan body types. I also referenced low-drag modern electric sedans, such as Tesla Model 3 and Lucid Air, which have large, flat underbody panels in the rear. However, the effectiveness of this rear diffuser entirely depends on the airflow staying attached in the front 2/3 of the underbody. With the stock airdam and largely uncovered front underbody, my diffuser would be mostly ineffective until I made better flat paneling on the front  2/3 of the underbody. In hindsight, I should have started modifying with a front-to-back technique, instead of starting in the rear.

The diffuser is made of .125" ABS sheet, although .093" ABS would have been better, being sufficiently rigid and weighing less. ABS is a thermoplastic, and gets softer as it heats up, so heat shield material from a salvage yard was cut and riveted in place to protect the ABS from the muffler's heat. Given the dearth of mounting locations in the rear underbody, a steel angle frame was constructed to add solid mounting locations to the center of the diffuser. The steel frame is bolted to the unibody using the same two mounting points as the optional Z-link suspension cross-member, which was deleted on Eco Models as a matter of weight/cost savings. The existing threaded holes for M12 bolts on each side were very convenient. Five equally-spaced rivnuts were pressed into the steel frame, allowing 5 central mounting points for the diffuser. The 90-degree bends in the ABS on either side of the heat shielding stand against the rear coil springs, and help prevent both air and water from going above the diffuser.

Along with the steel frame mounting, the existing underbody tray (toward front of car) and the rear bumper were drilled and used as mounting points for blind plastic fasteners. In it's final position, the rear muffler was nearly flush with the diffuser, allowing for heat transfer but also smooth air flow. The final diffuser angle from muffler to rear is 12 degrees. After 4 months of driving and testing, I have proven this diffuser design to be safe to use at at all speeds and in any weather conditions. The effectiveness of this diffuser heavily depends on the underbody panels in front of it. The flatter I can make the front 2/3 of the underbody, the more significant will be the effect of the rear diffuser.

Wheel Cover Prototypes

March 2023

The SAE technical paper utilized for the rear diffuser also mentioned the effect of flat wheel covers on overall drag coefficient. In addition to a flat rear diffuser, the researchers added full, flat wheel covers to the test sedan. They found the greatest drag reduction on sedan body types came from a fully covering over the rear wheel only, so that is what I decided to do first. 


I experimented with different designs, front covers, and various attachment methods. The best attachment method I had at the time was zipties around the spokes, which stuck out on the wheel as shown. Not only did this damage my wheels' finish through vibration, it also detracted from the aerodynamic benefit of the covers. As I came to find out, attachment method is one of the biggest engineering challenges when implementing wheel covers. It is no easy feat to design an attachment method which does not protrude from the wheel face, and allows for easy access to the lug nuts and valve stem. I did not see my MPG rise very significantly with a combination of full rear / partial front wheel covers and the rear diffuser, maybe 0.5-1 MPG total


Air Pressure Testing

Prior to altering any front-end undertrays, I needed a method for ensuring the vehicle’s cooling requirements would be maintained. In the Cruze, the cooling air which passes through the radiator is exhausted through the underbody and the wheel well gaps. So, covering up more of the underbody under the engine bay would effectively reduce the area of the cooling air exit path. Restricting the cooling air exit too much can raise the pressure in the engine bay, and reduce the pressure differential across the cooling package, reducing its cooling potential. Therefore, it was critical I obtain pressure readings in front of, and behind the cooling package in its stock form. 


I used a differential manometer, which provided me with the difference in air pressure of two different ports. So, I would get a positive or negative pressure in comparison to port 1, which read pressure in the vehicle cabin (with windows up). I fed the second port’s silicone hose from the manometer, through the door panel, through the front fender, and into the engine bay. Once in the engine bay, the hose was secured in various locations, with the hose’s opening perpendicular to the direction of air to get static pressure readings.


I measured the static pressure in front of the radiator, behind the cooling fan, and at the top of the engine bay at various high speeds (40MPH-80MPH). My use case of concern was highway speeds only, as this is when pressure may build up in the engine bay and limit cooling. Under 45 MPH, the Active Grill Shutter opens and practically doubles the cooling capacity at low speeds and idle. With these highway pressure measurements, I can now accurately assess the restrictions in cooling capacity of my underbody modifications.


Front Undertray Prototype

April 2023

With the rear underbody diffuser in place, it was time to increase airflow under the car. The large front airdam was removed and a prototype coroplast board with 3-Dimensional Wheel spoilers was put in place. The prototype was a pretty rough job, with lots of duct tape to seal the front edge.  Despite this, I saw a measurable increase in MPG over about 2,000 miles with this attached. 

The prototype results encouraged me to continue optimizing the front end undertrays. In an ideal world, I would have performed testing to see if drag was reduced, however, with limited time and limited resources I only used MPG data.  I do not recommend using duct tape for extended periods of time on painted surfaces as I did. The duct tape residue took hours to remove!

Engine Undertray Improvement

May 2023

Thermal considerations are one of the biggest challenges of making underbody aerodynamic pieces, as the exhuast system generally occupies the same real estate. In the Cruze, this was especially challenging, as the exhaust manifold faces toward the front of the car. Since the exhaust runs underneath the engine, I had no choice but to use metal, not plastic, to make my engine undertray. I chose 5052 aluminum sheet of 0.050 inch thickness, as it was the cheapest aluminum sheet option at my local metal supplier. To attach it to the car, I utilized the existing undertray and cut the middle section out. Plastic rivets were used along the sides, and the rear was attached using existing, but unused, threaded holes in an exhaust support.

I knew this aluminum undertray would reduce the cooling air flow over the exhaust, and would reflect radiated exhaust heat back up into the engine compartment. So, I decided to wrap the covered section of exhaust to ensure nothing melts or catches on fire, and to bring down overall engine bay temperatures. With exhaust wraps, pipe corrosion always becomes a concern, however the full undertray should keep a majority of moisture away from the wrapped area. In winter months, I will be removing the heat shield directly under the oil pan to encourage faster warm-up times.

The installed undertray was large and covered most of the engine compartment. Cooling air flow could still flow out through the exhaust tunnel at the rear of the shield. The fasteners were later optimized to protrude less and disturb the airflow less. To have the greatest affect on drag, a front bumper panel was required such that attached airflow could be guided to my new engine undertray. As such, a smooth front undertray was developed simultaneously to the engine undertray and is discussed in the next section.

Final Front Undertray

June 2023

The OEM front undertray had been optimized for use with a large airdam, meaning it had many vents, holes, and protrusions. I chose to remove the airdam, remove the OEM panel, and replace them with a smooth ABS panel which gradually slopes downward. This new setup would encourage air to flow under the car instead of around the car. However I will still be utilizing air deflectors to deflect air around the tires and wheel wells.

To fasten the new panel to the car, I used 4 existing screw locations along the subframe and 3/8" blind push-type fasteners along the leading edge of the panel. I chose blind push fasteners because they have an extremely flat head that would not protrude and disturb the airflow. To give the panel a slight downward bend, I used a heat gun to heat the ABS and bend it into the desired shape. The thermoplastic ability to permanently bend ABS is one of the main advantages of using it as an aero panel material.

Though I had a template to use, the leading edge of the panel did not fit perfectly flush with the leading edge of the bumper. I used a grinder to grind down the leading edge and give it a slanted shape. The goal was to have a smooth as possible transition from the bumper to the undertray, and foster an attached airflow to glide down the rest of the underbody.

Prototype Wheel Spoilers

June 2023

Preventing air from hitting the front tires is key to a low-drag car, and typically small deflectors are used. A cheap, but effective option is using a flat plate to block the air, but this is not ideal as it adds to front lift and drag. A 3-Dimensional deflector would be an ideal way to redirect airflow around the tire and wheel wells. In my research I've found most low-drag production cars block the tire with a deflector which is, at lowest, 100mm-120mm from the ground. My prototype deflector blocks an area that is 55mm tall, 200mm wide, and leaves 105mm of ground clearance. It is constructed with folded coroplast board and duct tape, and secured with duct tape.

Tires, Wheels, Wheel Covers

July 2023

Wheels and tires are one of the largest producers of of resistance on any ground vehicle, from both friction resistance and air resistance. Tires contact the ground and produce heat, and rotating wheels and spokes churn up the air and create detached airflow. Obviously, the wheels must still rotate in order to propel the vehicle, however there are 3 main strategies that can be used to decrease the resistance caused by wheels and tires.


Changing the Size and Proportions of the Wheels and Tires

I researched the tire sizing and MPG figures of every modern sedan of similar weight, and found common themes among tire sizing. Generally, smaller diameter wheels and larger sidewalls are better for MPG. In most modern sedans, the lowest trim models have the best MPG, largely due to their smaller wheels and taller sidewall tires.

In my case, I had lightweight forged aluminum 17x7 wheels with 215/55/R17 tires, which together weighed around 42.5lb. This OEM setup was fairly good for MPG, but I think it could be improved. I decided to change to a 16x6.5 steel wheel with 205/65/R16 tire, which together weighed around 40.5lb. Despite steel wheels weighing more than forged aluminum wheels, the reduction in wheel width and diameter allowed me to lose 2lb per wheel. Also, the overall diameter was very similar to the OEM setup, so I didn't have to worry about odometer/speedometer errors. Finally, the new tires are slightly thinner, which may slightly reduce aerodynamic drag. 


Using Low Rolling Resistance Tires

I chose to buy 205/65/R16 Michelin Energy Saver A/S tires, because they had a good reputation for low rolling resistance and they were on sale for $119 each. From my research, the tires best for maximizing MPG were the Michelin Energy Savers and the Bridgestone Ecopia EP422+, although their wet performance and noise characteristics were average at best.


Making the Face of the Wheel Smooth as Possible

Attaching a smooth wheel cover was an unanticipated engineering challenge. Finding a fastening system which does not protrude from the wheel face is critical, as any protrusions will rotate very quickly and thwart the effect of a smooth cover. My solution was buying 16-inch mooneye hubcaps, which are designed to go over steel wheels. These metal disks domes come in two attachment styles: Screw-on or Clip-on. The screw-on hubcaps require drilling/tapping threads into the steel wheel, which I was not comfortable doing. The clip-on disks have a ring of hooks on the backside which clip into place without the need for fasteners. Despite some people saying they do not stay in place, I decided to buy the clip-on versions. Within 500 miles of driving, I lost my first wheel cover. So, I decided to make a more secure attachment method, which can be seen in the pictures to the left. I cut the OEM hubcaps and screwed them to externally-threaded lugnuts. Then, I secured a bolt to the OEM hubcap, drilled a hole in the center of the new wheel cover, and fastened the new wheel cover to that bolt using a low-profile specialty nut (with med. strength Loctite). 

More Underbody Panels

September 2023

Though smoothing the front half of the underbody generally has larger drag coefficient reduction potential, adding smooth middle underbody panels still reduces drag and is essential to creating an effective rear diffuser. I utilized the same 0.050" 5052 Aluminum sheet as used previous panels. I used a series of brackets to make the middle panel flush with the existing front underbody tray. The large middle muffler is incorporated into the undertray, to make one relatively flat panel and allow for exhaust cooling.


Transmission Temperature Sensor

October 2023

I installed a Glowshift temperature sensor kit, which is installed into the drain plug, to monitor transmission temperatures. Since my aerodynamics modifications limit engine bay cooling, I need to make sure my manual transmission does not overheat - particularly during road trips in the summer. For manual transmissions, a steady-state operating temperature of 175-215F is desired for maximum longevity. I can now see real time temperature data for transmission fluid, antifreeze, and engine oil, to make sure nothing is overheating.

Winter Wheel Covers

October 2023

I created full wheel covers for my OEM wheels/tires so that I could have a second set for winter. Once I use up these all-season tires, they will be replaced with true winter tires. The covers are made of 1mm ABS and are slightly convex. The rivets on the outside edge hold brackets to the backside of the wheel. Zipties then loop through the brackets and around the spoke to hold the cover to the wheel. I used cheap, small zipties and had a few of these fly off on the interstate, but after upgrading to heavy duty, thicker zipties they have remained attached for months.

Active Grill Shutter Indicator LED

November 2023

Interested to determine the behavior of my OEM grill shutter system, I wired a rolling ball tilt switch to a 12V powered circuit with an LED. When the AGS is open, a blue LED in the cabin lights up, and when the AGS is closed, the blue LED turns off. 

Although it is effective, I would not recommend using a rolling ball tilt switch, as the blue LED does flicker when going over large bumps in the road, which can get annoying at night. To minimize annoyance, I reduced the brightness of the LED so it is barely visible during the day and dim at night. Brightness of the LED is simply adjusted by adding resistance to the circuit, higher resistance results in a dimmer LED. So, I continued to solder in larger and larger resistors until I was happy with the brightness.

The rolling ball tilt switch is ziptied to an angled ABS bracket in such a way that the ball falls away from the wire contacts when the grill shutters are closed. I used heat shrink to encase the tilt switch so water would not get in and corrode the delicate circuitry.

Engine Bay Vents

February 2024

I added  2 directional vents to the underbody trays: one vent is placed directly below the flex pipe, and one placed directly below the secondary catalytic converter. They are about 5" x 10" and were purchased from the local hardware store. Ideally, these vents would be inverted NACA ducts, as the ultimate low-drag vent. However, I could not find a single metal NACA duct for sale!

The purpose of these vents is to draw air out of the engine bay using the low pressures under the car, thereby lowering the pressure and temperature in the engine bay. Lower engine bay pressure increases the effectiveness of the radiator, and lower engine bay temperatures increase the lifespan of plastic/rubber components. 

If cooling becomes a problem during the upcoming summer months (75-90F Temps) I will likely need to add more vents, and may choose NACA ducts made of plastic, and locate them away from the exhaust.


Rear Wheel Fairings

March  2024

I wanted to make a removable wheel fairing, without drilling into the sheet metal. To do this, I created 4 aluminum brackets which attach to the plastic fender liner. Since the fender liner is not super strong, I had to make the fairing as light as possible. I used 2mm ABS as it was the perfect balance of rigidity and lightness.

Wool tuft testing later showed attached flow across the fairing, and much more flow attachment behind the rear wheel. This should reduce the size of the wake, and reduce turbulence created by the rear wheel. Since more flow is staying attached to the end of the car, I will need to create a new separation edge below the tail light to create a clean separation of this new flow.

In addition to being functional, the black color of the fairing blends in well with the rest of the wheel well. It is certainly noticeable, but this mod will not attract much attention, particularly police attention. I think it looks pretty slick too - very retro futuristic.

Revised Summer Wheel Covers

May 2024

Last summer, I used the previously-mentioned mooneye-style hubcaps which looked cool, but were too convex and stuck out from the side of the car. Although they were fully smooth, I think they added drag overall. So I decided to create a completely flat wheel cover with a similar look. 

I fastened a circle of .025" thick aluminum sheet to the OEM hubcaps with M4 rivnuts and stainless steel low-profile fasteners. I then bent the edge of the aluminum sheet over the rim of the hubcap such that it wouldn't flap in the wind. This design has proven secure at highway speeds, effective at reducing drag, and visually appealing. This will be the final iteration of wheel covers for the Cruze, and this design would be my recommendation to anyone looking to do this in the future. 

On my first highway trip with these covers installed, the Cruze averaged 48.8MPG, and the odometer crossed 200,000 miles. While a number of factors led to this fantastic result, it is a personal record for a full tank of gas, indicating these modifications are indeed working.